It's not easy to write convincing fiction when one of the characters is a great artist. The explanations of the art and its greatness usually fall flat.
Two embarrassing examples from Ayn Rand's novels
come to my mind instantly. In the opening
pages of
Atlas Shrugged, the theme of a mysterious symphony keeps popping
up, one that is brilliant and perfect precisely because it was
never written (oooh, that's spooky!). The other example comes from the
The Fountainhead: Howard Roark's architectural masterpieces
are left mainly to the imagination in the novel (I presume—I never
read it) but must be shown in the movie version because of the nature of the medium. This showing is not to Roark's advantage because the artists hired
to create the architectural drawings and matte paintings inevitably relied on
clichés, because if they were geniuses like Roark they wouldn't be
working in Hollywood. (One friend's reaction upon seeing
those "masterpieces" was to blurt out, "he invented the 1950's!").
Two works of fiction from the world of SF feature characters who are
musicians, and to my delight get them mostly
right. First is Ian R. MacLeod's
Song of Time. A supporting character, prominent
in the first few chapters (the ones I've read so far) is a brilliant young pianist
who dies a slow death, but not before transmitting his passion for music to his
sister, the main character. I'm amazed to report that some of the lad's advice
on the topic of practicing is
actually useful. Amazing.
The other musician, a composer actually, is the first-person main
character of the short story
Empire of Ice Cream by Jeffery Ford,
available from my good friends over at the
Starship Sofa Podcast. I thought
it regrettable that the story told of a magnum opus
consisting of two-voice
counterpoint (only two? To carry an extended work? I doubt it) but otherwise the
depiction of the life and work of a composer felt right to
me. As a bonus, the character
is also a synaesthete, one of a group that, long-time readers know (hi Mom!), I have made the butt of good-natured jokes here at the Fredösphere (if
jokes about
concentration camps can ever be good-natured. . . and
I say, when they're about
synaesthetes, they are!).
Labels: AynRand, Composition, Creativity, MusicTheory, Starship Sofa, Synaesthetes